Skip to main content

Should we punish criminals?

Author
Affiliation

David W. Agler

The Pennsylvania State University

Abstract
Slides for Metaphysics.

Goals and Agenda

Key questions

  1. What is the relation between punishment and free will?
  2. Should we punish criminals?
  3. Can we punish criminals even if they are not free?

Goals

  1. Answer the questions

Punish Criminals? Yes

NoteRetributive theory of punishment
  1. it is morally permissible to punish criminals because they deserve to be punished (even if punishing them will do no good),
  2. it is morally impermissible to punish innocent people, and
  3. the punishment of criminals should be proportionate to their wrongdoing.

Further clarifications

  1. Axiom: “Eye for an eye”
  2. Consistency: Punishing criminals is simply the application of the moral rules they live by on themselves.
  3. Intuitive: bad people deserve bad things to happen to them.
  4. No alternative: denying any of the claims is unworkable.

Exercise

NoteExercise

The retributive theory of punishment requires that punishments be proportionate. State a bad action and state a punishment that is not proportionate.

Retributive theory and free will

Retributive theory seems to imply free will because:

  • P1. You can only punish people for an action \(A\) iff they are responsible for that action.
  • P2. If you are responsible for an action \(A\), then you had some choice (free will) relating to \(A\).
  • C. Therefore, if you can punish people, free will exists.

flowchart LR
    P[Punishment is justified]
    R[Responsibility]
    F[Free will]

P <--> R
R --> F

Responses

flowchart LR
    P[Punishment is justified]
    R[Responsibility]
    F[Free will]

P <--> R
R --> F

  1. Deny free will and punishment. There is no free will and therefore it is never morally acceptable to punish criminals.
  2. Deny free will but accept punishment. Punishment is justified but it either (1) does not entail responsibility or (2) require free will.

Three theories

Let’s explore this option:

it is morally permissible to punish a person even if there is no free will (and so they are not responsible)because it results in better social outcomes.

  1. Deterrence theory
  2. Rehabilitation theory
  3. Quarantine theory

Deterrence

  1. Suppose Tek commits a criminal act.
  2. Act was not free
NoteDeterrence theory

It is morally permissible to “punish” people (even if their actions were not free) to “deter” them (or others) from committing wrongdoing in the future.

Justified because it increases social good by preventing future crimes through disincentivising it.

Examples

  1. Automatic F in course for cheating
  2. Jail time for speeding
  3. Crucifixion or (hanging, drawing, and quartering) for traitors

Problem 1

It is not clear that some severe punishments (e.g., prison sentence) deter crime.

  1. Teaches new criminal skills: Prisons exacerbate recidivism.
  2. Criminals tend to ignore punishments
  3. People “age out” of crime (approximately 35).

Response

Need to revise our concept of deterrence in line with empirical science

  1. Certainty of getting caught and punished is more of a deterrent than severity of punishment.
  2. Make criminals more aware of punishments
  3. End long sentences (aging out)

Problem 2

Deterrence theory is consistent with punishing innocent people.

  • Punishing people is justified even if they are not responsible for the action (not free)
  • Justification is found in the social good promoted by deterring future crimes.

Response

Bite bullet

  1. It is ok to punish innocents.
  2. Just need to make sure no one finds out (social panic / outrage)

Quarantine

  1. Suppose Tek commits a criminal act.
  2. Act was not free
NoteQuarantine theory

It is morally permissible to “punish” people (even if their actions were not free) by quarantining them.

NoteQuarantine

To restrict the movement of an individual, group of individuals, or some item in order to prevent the spread of a disease, virus, or pest.

Examples

  • Prisons
  • “The Hole” (SHU), Solitary confinement
  • House arrest
  • Deportation (of immigrants)
  • Termination from job
  • Deserted islands
  • School detention

Clarification

  • Analogy: If people have a sickness (virus) that could harm others, we separate them from society.
  • Person is not evil, responsible, and does not deserve to suffer. They are just dangerous to society.
  • Justified by self-defense: protecting society from you

Problems

  1. Predictive problem: Assumes we can determine who will commit future crimes.
  2. Proportionality: Consistent with short quarantine for heinous crime and long quarantine for minor crime.
  3. Pre-crime: Consistent with quarantine of individuals who are likely to commit a crime.
  4. Individual vs. Society: Many people do “bad actions” because of the societal-economic-environal situation, but we are quarantining the individual.

Exercise

NoteExercise

Which of the objections seems most powerful as criticism of the quarantine theory?

Rehabilitation

  1. Suppose Tek commits a criminal act.
  2. Act was not free
NoteRehabilitation theory

It is morally permissible to “punish” people (even if their actions were not free) to “rehabilitate them”.

Again, social good is the justification for “punishment”, not because they “deserve it”.

Criminal rehabilitation

  • Many different concepts of “criminal rehabilitation” (confusing)
  • Debate about whether some activities could as “rehabilitation”, e.g., chemical castration (drugs to reduce sex hormones) or brain-altering drugs.

Criminal rehabilitation?

Roughly five theories of criminal rehabilitation. We’ll pick one:

NoteCriminal rehabilitation

Rehabilitation is anti-recidivism. An rehabilitative act \(A\) administered on a subject \(S\) is an instance of criminal rehabilitation just in the case that:

  1. it will likely to reduce the likelihood that \(S\) will commit a criminally bad act, AND
  2. \(A\) does not reduce \(S\)’s capacity to reoffend or disincentivizing future bad acts by \(A\)

Different from deterrence

Similar to deterrence theory in that it aims to reduce future bad acts

  1. Not by harming \(S\), e.g., chopping off hands, execution
  2. Separation of \(S\) and victims (prison)
  3. Not through fear and trembling.

Examples

  1. Change the agent so that they can reoffend but they want other things
  2. Increased self-control, empathy, education, introspection, stronger social bonds, etc.

More specifically:

  1. Education (GED)
  2. Occupational Training
  3. Substance abuse treatment
  4. Mental Health Rehabilitation

Exercise

NoteExercise

What is an example of a rehabilitation that you see in society for bad behavior (does not need to be criminal)?

Problems

  1. Predictive problem: Assumes we can determine who is cured.
  2. Proportionality: Consistent with short short therapy for heinous crime and long therapy for minor crime.
  3. Pre-crime: Consistent with quarantine of individuals who are likely to commit a crime.
  4. Individual vs. Society: Many people do “bad actions” because of the societal-economic-environal situation, but we are rehabing the individual.

Exercise

NoteExercise

We’ve isolated different theories of punishment, but we might use a hybrid theory. Create your own version.