flowchart LR
P[Punishment is justified]
R[Responsibility]
F[Free will]
P <--> R
R --> F
Should we punish criminals?
Goals and Agenda
Key questions
- What is the relation between punishment and free will?
- Should we punish criminals?
- Can we punish criminals even if they are not free?
Goals
- Answer the questions
Punish Criminals? Yes
Further clarifications
- Axiom: “Eye for an eye”
- Consistency: Punishing criminals is simply the application of the moral rules they live by on themselves.
- Intuitive: bad people deserve bad things to happen to them.
- No alternative: denying any of the claims is unworkable.
Exercise
Retributive theory and free will
Retributive theory seems to imply free will because:
- P1. You can only punish people for an action \(A\) iff they are responsible for that action.
- P2. If you are responsible for an action \(A\), then you had some choice (free will) relating to \(A\).
- C. Therefore, if you can punish people, free will exists.
Responses
flowchart LR
P[Punishment is justified]
R[Responsibility]
F[Free will]
P <--> R
R --> F
- Deny free will and punishment. There is no free will and therefore it is never morally acceptable to punish criminals.
- Deny free will but accept punishment. Punishment is justified but it either (1) does not entail responsibility or (2) require free will.
Three theories
Let’s explore this option:
it is morally permissible to punish a person even if there is no free will (and so they are not responsible)because it results in better social outcomes.
- Deterrence theory
- Rehabilitation theory
- Quarantine theory
Deterrence
- Suppose Tek commits a criminal act.
- Act was not free
Justified because it increases social good by preventing future crimes through disincentivising it.
Examples
- Automatic F in course for cheating
- Jail time for speeding
- Crucifixion or (hanging, drawing, and quartering) for traitors
Problem 1
It is not clear that some severe punishments (e.g., prison sentence) deter crime.
- Teaches new criminal skills: Prisons exacerbate recidivism.
- Criminals tend to ignore punishments
- People “age out” of crime (approximately 35).
Response
Need to revise our concept of deterrence in line with empirical science
- Certainty of getting caught and punished is more of a deterrent than severity of punishment.
- Make criminals more aware of punishments
- End long sentences (aging out)
Problem 2
Deterrence theory is consistent with punishing innocent people.
- Punishing people is justified even if they are not responsible for the action (not free)
- Justification is found in the social good promoted by deterring future crimes.
Response
Bite bullet
- It is ok to punish innocents.
- Just need to make sure no one finds out (social panic / outrage)
Quarantine
- Suppose Tek commits a criminal act.
- Act was not free
Examples
- Prisons
- “The Hole” (SHU), Solitary confinement
- House arrest
- Deportation (of immigrants)
- Termination from job
- Deserted islands
- School detention
Clarification
- Analogy: If people have a sickness (virus) that could harm others, we separate them from society.
- Person is not evil, responsible, and does not deserve to suffer. They are just dangerous to society.
- Justified by self-defense: protecting society from you
Problems
- Predictive problem: Assumes we can determine who will commit future crimes.
- Proportionality: Consistent with short quarantine for heinous crime and long quarantine for minor crime.
- Pre-crime: Consistent with quarantine of individuals who are likely to commit a crime.
- Individual vs. Society: Many people do “bad actions” because of the societal-economic-environal situation, but we are quarantining the individual.
Exercise
Rehabilitation
- Suppose Tek commits a criminal act.
- Act was not free
Again, social good is the justification for “punishment”, not because they “deserve it”.
Criminal rehabilitation
- Many different concepts of “criminal rehabilitation” (confusing)
- Debate about whether some activities could as “rehabilitation”, e.g., chemical castration (drugs to reduce sex hormones) or brain-altering drugs.
Criminal rehabilitation?
Roughly five theories of criminal rehabilitation. We’ll pick one:
Different from deterrence
Similar to deterrence theory in that it aims to reduce future bad acts
- Not by harming \(S\), e.g., chopping off hands, execution
- Separation of \(S\) and victims (prison)
- Not through fear and trembling.
Examples
- Change the agent so that they can reoffend but they want other things
- Increased self-control, empathy, education, introspection, stronger social bonds, etc.
More specifically:
- Education (GED)
- Occupational Training
- Substance abuse treatment
- Mental Health Rehabilitation
Exercise
Problems
- Predictive problem: Assumes we can determine who is cured.
- Proportionality: Consistent with short short therapy for heinous crime and long therapy for minor crime.
- Pre-crime: Consistent with quarantine of individuals who are likely to commit a crime.
- Individual vs. Society: Many people do “bad actions” because of the societal-economic-environal situation, but we are rehabing the individual.