flowchart LR
P[Punishment is justified]
R[Responsibility]
F[Free will]
P <--> R
R --> F
The Pennsylvania State University
Key questions
Goals
Retributive theory of punishment
Exercise
The retributive theory of punishment requires that punishments be proportionate. State a bad action and state a punishment that is not proportionate.
Retributive theory seems to imply free will because:
flowchart LR
P[Punishment is justified]
R[Responsibility]
F[Free will]
P <--> R
R --> F
flowchart LR
P[Punishment is justified]
R[Responsibility]
F[Free will]
P <--> R
R --> F
Let’s explore this option:
it is morally permissible to punish a person even if there is no free will (and so they are not responsible)because it results in better social outcomes.
Deterrence theory
It is morally permissible to “punish” people (even if their actions were not free) to “deter” them (or others) from committing wrongdoing in the future.
Justified because it increases social good by preventing future crimes through disincentivising it.
It is not clear that some severe punishments (e.g., prison sentence) deter crime.
Need to revise our concept of deterrence in line with empirical science
Deterrence theory is consistent with punishing innocent people.
Bite bullet
Quarantine theory
It is morally permissible to “punish” people (even if their actions were not free) by quarantining them.
Quarantine
To restrict the movement of an individual, group of individuals, or some item in order to prevent the spread of a disease, virus, or pest.
Exercise
Which of the objections seems most powerful as criticism of the quarantine theory?
Rehabilitation theory
It is morally permissible to “punish” people (even if their actions were not free) to “rehabilitate them”.
Again, social good is the justification for “punishment”, not because they “deserve it”.
Roughly five theories of criminal rehabilitation. We’ll pick one:
Criminal rehabilitation
Rehabilitation is anti-recidivism. An rehabilitative act \(A\) administered on a subject \(S\) is an instance of criminal rehabilitation just in the case that:
Similar to deterrence theory in that it aims to reduce future bad acts
More specifically:
Exercise
What is an example of a rehabilitation that you see in society for bad behavior (does not need to be criminal)?
Exercise
We’ve isolated different theories of punishment, but we might use a hybrid theory. Create your own version.