Evidence for time travel

David W. Agler

The Pennsylvania State University

Evidence for time travel

Philosophy and time travel

Time travel is explored in philosophy and fiction.

But, has anyone or anything ever traveled through time?

Let’s examine the affirmative answer.

Convincing evidence

Some people have their beliefs and no amount of evidence would ever change their minds.

What evidence would change your mind?

Goals:

  1. Decide if anyone has ever time traveled.
  2. Develop a criterion for deciding what evidence would decide the matter

The Evidentiary Argument

  • P1: There is evidence that people or things have travelled through time.
  • C: Therefore, time travel is actual.

What sort of evidence is cited to support P1?

Four kinds of evidence

  1. People have traveled through time (time travelers)
  2. There are objects (technologies) from the future in the past
  3. Time machines
  4. Claims from scientists (testimony about experiments)

People have traveled through time

Argument from Time Travelers

  • P1: There is evidence that people or things have travelled through time since Person S claims to be a time traveler.
  • C: Therefore, time travel exists (or is likely).

Everything rests on P1 (argument from testimony).

Time Travelers

Two main types of people claiming to be time travelers:

  1. Past to future travelers
  2. Future to past travelers

Mike “Madman” Marcum

  • This is Mike “Madman” Marcum.
  • In 1995 Marcum called into AM radio saying he built TM

Picture of Mike Marcum

Early experiments

  • Early tests using modified Jacob’s ladder (using a laser)
  • Small objects (e.g., screws) disappeared and reappeared (temporary invisibility?)
  • Built a larger one and repeated tests (made a couch disappear)

Picture of Jacob’s ladder

Blackouts

  • Stole power transformers from the power company to build a TM that sends large objects into the future.
  • Marcum’s theft and TM caused blackouts
  • Police arrested Marcum for stealing power transformers (60 days)

Marcum

  • Marcum gained popularity after being interviewed on a radio show. Later Radio Interview
  • People donated money, power, transformers, etc.
  • He built a new TM, trying it on larger objects and animals.
  • Ultimately, he tried it on himself and disappeared.

Marcum: Reappearance

  • Years later Marcum reappeared, said he was transported into the future.
  • 800 miles away, suffered amnesia.
  • When his memory returned, he claimed to need money to recreate the TM.

bg right

Exercise

Alt text

Marcum claims to have traveled through time. Are you convinced? If you are, you can donate to his Patreon.

Problem

  • Marcum traveled from the present to the future and so testimony is harder to substantiate.
  • If someone claims they are from the past, they could be lying, cosplaying, larping, etc.
  • Criterion: Theory needs predictions that can be verified

Alt text

Future Travelers

Future travelers

  • Future travelers can use future knowledge to prove they traveled through time.
  • Theory: Time travel has occurred
  • Test: If so, tell me about the future.

John Titor

  • In 2000 and 2001, John Titor claimed to be from 2036 on a military mission to prevent dystopian future
  • In online forums, he society had crumbled and encouraged people to begin stockpiling food
  • TT was developed in Switzerland by CERN (European Organization for Nuclear Research)
  • CERN created the Hadron Collider (September 2008)

Problem 1: False predictions

Said the Russians nuked the US in 2015 and a second Civil War.

Nah.

But wait! Evidence it didnt happen is proof Titor altered the future

Problem 2: Vague predictions

First mission was to go back to 1975 to get IBM 5100 because it could “speak” multiple coding languages.

IBM5100 Wikipedia

IBM5100 Wikipedia

TikTok traveler

Problems

The obvious problem with the time traveler on Tik Tok is that his predictions are:

  1. Verifiably false (e.g., GTA VI came out Nov. 19, 2026)
  2. Practically Unverifiable: Too far into the future to verify
  3. Not novel and unspecific. There will be a war in the future.

Alt text

Criterion

Predictions need to be unusual, specific, and true.

  1. Tomorrow the sun will rise tomorrow vs. 
  2. Buy a lottery ticket tomorrow with the numbers 11193034.

Let’s look at a novel prediction from a time traveler.

Stock trading: unusual results

  • On 25 February 2003 an article was posted to Weekly World News (WWN)
  • Reported a 44-year-old stock trader (Andrew Carlssin) was arrested on insider-trading charges.
  • Carlssin transformed a $800 into $350 million dollars in two weeks via stock trading.

Newspaper clipping from Weekly World News

Plea Deal

  • The Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) took this as evidence that Carlssin was using insider information.
  • After arrest, Carlssin claimed to be a time traveler from 2256.
  • A Yahoo article would report that Carlssin, in his four-hour videotaped interrogation offered information in exchange for a lighter sentence.

Novel predictions

  • He offered to reveal the location of Osama Bin Laden
  • The cure for AIDS.

The article was later reprinted by several news outlets, including Yahoo! Entertainment in a 19 March 2003 by Chad Kultgen.

Predictions are True!

  • WWN later reported that while being held at Rikers Island, he predicted the exact date that the US would invade Iraq.
  • On 29 March 2003, Carlssin was released after an unidentified individual paid his $1 million bail. Carlssin subsequently disappeared.

Alt text

Exercise

Exercise

  1. Testimony of a time-traveler
  2. Supporting testimony of a third-party source (news sources) that the traveler’s predictions were true.
  3. Predictions were unusual (novel) and specific

Are you convinced?

Answer

This is fake news. Weekly World News was a tabloid that published various outlandish stories, many focusing on supernatural events. WWN also published stories that include:

  • the original apple from the Garden of Eden had been discovered
  • that a human bat child was found in a cave
  • Dick Cheney is a robot.

Trusting Sources

  • Other news sources would occasionally take stories from WWN to be legit.
  • Example: it was reported that Fox & Friends relied upon a 2010 WWN article that reported the Los Angeles Police Department was planning to purchase 10,000 jet packets for police, paramedics, and fire departments (costly roughly 1 billion dollars).LAPD_jetpacks

Criterion Again

Revision: Evidence needs to be

  1. novel / unusual
  2. precise / specific
  3. either substantiated (more than just the word of the traveler) or from a trusted source, not testimony from sketchy “news” sources.

From Artefacts

The Evidence

  1. People have traveled through time (time travelers)
  2. There are objects (technologies) from the future in the past
  3. Time machines
  4. Claims from scientists (testimony about experiments)

Artefacts from the Future

Artefacts from the past not as convincing as those from the future.

  • P1: Artefact X does not belong in time period Y.
  • P2: The best explanation for artefact X at time Y involves time travel.
  • C: Therefore, there is evidence for time-travel having occurred.

Example

  • Suppose you are in the 1800s
  • A person claiming to be a time traveler arrives with a variety of objects created in the future
  • Clothes from the future or futuristic technologies, e.g., lasers, cellphones, self-driving car.
  • You might believe them b/c how else could they have those objects.

Reasoning

In examining these artefacts, you might reason as follows:

  • P1: These technologies are much more advanced than the technologies of the time period that I am presently in.
  • P2: These technologies were not created in this time period given the existing knowledge, resources, and / or existing technologies.
  • C: Therefore, these technologies are likely from the future.

Hipster Time-traveller

Hipster time traveler

  • Futuristic glasses
  • Graphic T
  • Modern DSLR camera
  • Late 20th century style

Alt text

Traveler in a Chaplin Film

Time Traveler in Chaplin

Alt text

Alt text
  • Woman talking while holding a cellphone.
  • Clarke claims he showed this clip to 100 people over the course of a year.
  • They thought she had a cell phone

Cellphone on a Beach

More evidence

  • Photograph from 1943
  • A man is looking at his cellphone.
  • See if you can find him.

Cellphone on a Beach

Alt text

  • People are enjoying the beach
  • Swimming, looking at others
  • One man is in ill-fitting clothes checking his text messages.

Iphones

  • P1: The first iPhone was released on 29 June 2007.
  • P2: There is evidence of iPhones existing before 2007.
  • P3: The best explanation of these early iPhones are that people traveled back in time with them.
  • C: Therefore, time travel is actual.

Alt text

1860 Painting

  • 1860 painting The Expected by Ferdinand Georg Waldmüller
  • A woman looking down on at her mobile phone.

Alt text

1937 Painting

1937 painting “Mr. Pynchon and the Settling of Springfield” by Italian painter Umberto Romano.

Alt text

Alt text

–>

Mike Tyson Fight

At this point, you might be complaining that a lot of this “evidence” is old.

  • What about some more recent evidence?
  • Also why would time travelers go back to these boring times and places?

Mike Tyson Fight

On 19 Aug 1995, American boxers Mike Tyson and Peter McNeeley fought at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas, Nevada.

Alt text

Who is Mike Tyson?

  • Famous boxer: Former Heavyweight Champion
  • Exciting boxer: Most recently fought Jake Paul
  • You might want to go back in time to watch him fight in his prime.

Alt text

Tyson vs. McNeeley (1995)

Alt text

Exercise

Evidence that time travel has occurred in the form of

  1. paintings
  2. photos
  3. videos

Exercise

They independently substantiate the testimony of time travelers. Is this enough evidence?

Inference to best explanation

Two competing explanation:

  1. What we see is explained by time-travel.
  2. What we see is explained in another way.

Provided we can provide a plausible interpretation of what we see that does not involve time travel, then we don’t need to believe that time travel has occurred.

How do we explain what we’ve seen without invoking time travel?

Explanation

  • Explanation 1: Time travel with phone.
  • Explanation 2: Looking at book (e.g., Bible) or mirror

Alt text

Modern Day Hipster

  1. Ballistic (protective) eyewear was available in North America since the 1880s
  2. Characteristic “M” on his is the same “M” used by the Montreal Maroons (1924-1938) a Canadian hockey team
  3. Portable cameras similar to the one the time traveler is holding have existed since at least the 1920s.

Alt text

Mike Tyson

Alt text

Alt text

Criterion

When evaluating the truth of some implausible hypothesis (e.g., miracle cures, fortunes, time-travel),

  1. Evidence from testimony needs to meet certain standards (precise, novel, capable of being verified, from reliable sources)
  2. Evidence from the existence of artefacts / phenomenon needs consider whether some more plausible (simpler) hypothesis explains the existence of the phenomenon, e.g., placebo

Exercise

  1. Do you believe in time travel?
  2. What kind of evidence would make you believe that someone is from the future?