The Pennsylvania State University
| Theory | A or B | Temp. ontology | Temp. passage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eternalist | B | eternalist | static |
| Presentist | A | presentist | dynamic (ontological) |
| Growing Block | A | past-presentist | dynamic (ontological) |
| Moving Spotlight | A | eternalist | dynamic (property) |
This time:
Next time:
Presentism
Ingram writes that “I say that there are two elements to presentism as a theory of time, an ontological thesis and a dynamical thesis.”
There is considerable debate about the presentist’s view of temporal ontology: only present stuff exists.
Presentists say the only entities that exist are in the present
Presentists do not have a unified view on abstracta:
Formulation (1) is a better explanation than formulation (2)
Applied to our own existence:
If someone where to love you, they would only need to love the you that is here right now (not a past or future you).
No. Distant times are not like distant places.
There are two different versions of presentism
Solipsism
Solipsism
Solipsism is a theory the only mind for which we can be certain that it exists is our own.
The basic argument for the theory usually depends upon
Solipsistic presentism
Solipsistic presentism is the theory that there is one and only one present that exists and that has ever existed. It is the one that we are in right now!
Where did these things come from?
If you accept past presents, you can say they once existed.
Solipsistic argument: we have direct (instaneous) knowledge of our own minds (of the present).
No, it is inferred.
Solipsistic presentism
Reality consists of successive present moments.
The old time \(t_1\) did exist (was present) but no longer exists.
A change to what exists ushers in a new time (new present)
Exercise
You know have the theory of presentism before you. Create a picture or diagram that captures the core idea of presentism. Feel free to label the diagram to make things clear.
Presentism is taken to be intuitive, common sense.
Challenge: is the theory really “more intuitive” or “agrees with common sense” more than otehr theories.
Similar arguments can be made for things that depend upon free will, e.g., moral responsibility, punishment, divine judgment.
Definition
The thinning-tree view of the universe is the view that (1) the future is an open set of possibilities (Open future) and (2) the passage of time plays a role in the actualization of these future possibilities.
Confinement doctrine
The only conscious experience we have is of present events: events occurring in the present in the world (confinement doctrine).
Exercise
What problems can you think of for the confinement doctrine?
Need a few definitions
Contingent Proposition
A proposition \(P\) is contingent if and only if there is some possible world \(w_1\) where \(P\) is true and some world \(w_2\) where \(P\) is false.
\(P\) is contingently true iff it is true in this world but false in at least some other possible world.
“David is 6’0.”
Grounding principle
Every contingently true proposition \(P\) about the world depends for its truth on the world.
“David is 6’0.””
truthmaking principle (TMP)
Necessarily, for any contingently true proposition \(P\), there exists something \(TM\) (its truthmaker) that makes \(P\) true.
Extra Credit
There are a few problems with explaining grounding using truthmaker principle. One approach is to use the supervenience principle. Read the portion of the book, explain supervenience, explain what problem of the truthmaking principle it solves.
Independent of the past principle
Past truths do not depend upon what happens in the present.
These facts do not depend upon present facts.
Presentist truth
A proposition \(P\) is true iff \(P\) is derivable from presently existing objects and their instantiation patterns.
What is true is what can be inferred about the past from the present state of affairs.
“Dinos existed.”
“This dino existed.”
Commit the perfect crime.
Another approach is not to say that past truths are made true by what is derivable from present facts, but past truths are made true by present facts.
Present record truthmaking
Past tensed truths are made true by the present way the world is.
My grandma is cremated.
“I loved my grandma”
Option 2 is more natural but implies past objects.
For normal grounding, we assume there is something that makes the sentence true.
P-grounding: Every true proposition depends for its truth on how the world was, is, or will be.
Westphal writes “a proposition can be true only if there is or was something in virtue of which it is true.”