The Pennsylvania State University
Definition
A time is what corresponds to a complete and consistent specification (snapshot, description, picture, account) of a world.
A theory of time is made of three parts (or three subtheories)
A set does not have order (unordered collection of unique objects)
\[A = \{3, 2, 1\}, \{2, 3, 1\}\]
A dimension refers to the number of coordinates needed to specify a point (something).
This is why we talk about a timeline.
There are two main ways that events are said to be temporally ordered.
Take a horizontal line and specify a point on that line (e.g., 0).
We can specify the position of other points from how far they are from this line.
Times can be ordered in the same way. Take a special time: the Present
We can specify the position of other times from how far they are from the present (e.g., two days from the present, or two days past).
This is one picture of the temporal ordering of the world
Definition
The A-series structures time in terms of the objective past, present, and future
There is a single present moment.
The B-series says time is ordered in terms of relations:
Definition
The B-series structures time in terms of earlier than, later than, simultaneous with
The B-series
Exercise
Consider point (3) by imagining that the order of events in our world was different. That is, consider some historical event (or event in your life) and move its temporal position, e.g., from distant past to near past, or from future to past.
We have two ways of ordering our world:
Now let’s consider two theories of temporal ordering:
A-theory
The world is ordered by the A-series and B-series
B-theory
The world is only ordered by B-series
Exercise
Are you an A-theorist or B-theorist?
There are three main theories:
Definition
The presentist theory of temporal ontology states that only present times (events) exist.
What exists is coextensive with what is in the present.
Example:
Objects in the past do not exist simpliciter
Definition
The eternalist theory of ontology says that all events in time exist in the same way (also called “permanentism” and “event everywhereism”)
Suppose this is your life:
The eternalist says all of these events exist.
Someone who accepts eternalist-TO is sometimes called a “spatializer” because time is analogous to space.
This is just like your life
A book is divided into chapters.
Definition
Past-presentist theory of temporal ontology states that only past and present events exist.
Events (1) and (2) exist in the same way you and I exist (simpliciter), but (3) only exists with qualification.
Which are you? Presentist, Eternalist, or Past-presentist?
Challenges:
Two main versions:
Both theories contend that change is a part of objective reality (not an illusion, not due to how we experience what exists).
Property change dynamic theory of temporal passage
Event: You dancing in the club.
On this theory of temporal passage, nothing ever changes other than an event’s temporal properties
The only change that occurs is the gain / loss of temporal properties
ontological change dynamic theory of temporal passage
Example 1: New object
Example 2: New property
The flow of time is explained in terms of
Consequence: Time does not flow in an frozen universe (against Newton’s absolutist view of time)
static theory of temporal passage
Which are you? Static theory, dynamic ontological, or dynamic property theorist?
| Theory | A or B | Temp. ontology | Temp. passage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eternalist | B | eternalist | static |
| Presentist | A | presentist | dynamic (ontological) |
| Growing Block | A | past-presentist | dynamic (ontological) |
| Moving Spotlight | A | eternalist | dynamic (property) |