Description
This is a study guide to help you prepare for the exam. While it aims
to be comprehensive, it is not guaranteed to cover every topic that may
appear on the exam. It is important to review all of your notes and the
course materials.
Questions
- What term (or phrase) corresponds to the following definition:
Object O is a person if and
only if O is capable of free
will.
- How is free will typically defined?
- What term corresponds to the following definition: There is at least
one humanlike creature that has free will.
- Suppose Tek desires to buy some cereal. There is nothing stopping
him from buying the cereal (nothing stopping him from acting on his
desires). Given the facts of this scenario, why might Tek fail
to be free?
- What term corresponds to the following definition: The contingent
and empirical claim that for every event e for which there is an earlier
state of the world, the total state of the world w at that earlier time t1 along with the all the
laws L entail every future
event at a later time t2.
- What term corresponds to the following definition: The contingent
and empirical claim that determinism is not true. There exists an event
e for which there is an
earlier state of the world such that the total state of the world w at that earlier time t1 along with the all the
laws L do not entail
every future event at a later time t2.
- If someone accepts determinism (or indeterminism), they are saying
that this proposition is contingently true. What does this mean?
- The world might be deterministic or indeterministic. According to
most philosophers (metaphysicians), who decides which way the world
is?
- What term best corresponds to the following definition: Free will is
metaphysically impossible for human-like creatures.
- What term best corresponds to the following definition: Free will is
metaphysically possible for human-like creatures even if the world is
deterministic.
- What term best corresponds to the following definition: If
determinism is true, then the free will thesis is false. That is, there
is no possible world that is (1) deterministic and (2) there are humans
with free will.
- According to the lecture and lecture notes, metaphysical free will
is important for at least two reasons. What are these two reasons?
Indicate both. Note that some of these choices may be additional reasons
why free will is important but you should only select the two explicitly
discussed in the lecture.
- What term or phrase best corresponds to X in the following definition: An
event e is X for S if and only if e will happen in every possible
scenario (and so e will happen
no matter what S does).
- What term or phrase corresponds to X in the following definition: An
event e is X for S if and only if (1) e will happen and (2) while there
are some possible scenarios will e will not happen, in any possible
scenario that is relevantly similar to the actual world where S would try to prevent e from occurring, S would be ignorant (or lack the
relevant power) to prevent e.
- What term or phrase corresponds to X in the following definition: A
future action E is X for a person S if and only if (1) e will happen in this world and (2)
it will happen for purely conceptual / logical reasons.
- Suppose Tek will eat a cupcake tomorrow. There is nothing he can do
to prevent eating the cupcake. That is, no matter how the world were
different or how Tek were different, Tek will eat the cupcake. The event
of eating the cupcake is what for Tek?
- Stong inevitabilism, weak inevitabilism, and fatalism are somewhat
difficult to distinguish from each other. However, they do share one key
feature in common. What is that feature?
- What is the name of the argument that says (roughly put): (1) Every
proposition P is either T or
F. (2) If P is T or F, then
you cannot change the truth value of P. (3) If you cannot change the
truth value of P, then you
cannot do not-P. (4) If you
cannot do not-P, then you do
not have the power to do P.
(5) If you do not have the power to do P and the power to do not-P, then you are not free. (6)
Therefore, you are not free.
- What is the name of the argument that says (roughly put): (1) If God
is eternal and divine, then God knows everything. (2) If God knows
everything, then God knows what you will do in the future. (3) If God
knows what you will do in the future, then (with respect to future
events) you cannot act in a way different than you do. (4) Therefore,
you are not free.
- Suppose Tek is watching his favorite anime Berserk. At the
beginning of the anime, the narrator says the following (with some
changes from the original): “The destiny of man is determined by the
will God. God knows what we desire, what we will desire, and how we will
act on those desires. There is nothing we can do to change that God
knows these things. Therefore, all of our actions are fated.” This
argument most closely approximates which argument?
- Most philosophers believe in what theory concerning free will?
- True or False. Incompatibilists say that free will is
impossible.
- True or False. Incompatibilists say that the world is
deterministic.
- True or False. Incompatibilists say that the world is
indeterministic.
- If incompatibilism is true, which of the following are true?
Indicate all that apply.
- What is the name of the primary argument in favor of
incompatibilism?
- A supporter of the Consequence Argument might argue that the
proposition “no one has, or ever had, any choice about whether p is the
case” (where p is some
proposition about the past) is true because p is in the past. What is wrong with
this argument?
- Suppose Mo has developed a character trait T that always leads him to smile
when other people smile at him (he has absolutely no control over this
trait). Liz walks past Mo and smiles at him. In response, Mo smiles at
Liz. Mo says that he is not responsible for smiling at Liz because (1)
he does not have (nor never had) any choice over the fact that he has
T since the trait is in the
past and (2) he can’t prevent the fact that trait T determines event E. What is problematic about this
argument? Call the event of Mo smiling at Liz, event E.
- Suppose a defender of the Consequence argumes the proposition “no
one has, or ever had, any choice about whether p is the case” (where
p is some proposition about
the past) is true because p
occurs at a time where no human being exists to do anything with respect
to p. What is the problem with
this argument if it is used to support incompatibilism?
- The compatibilist believes which one of the following?
- True of False. The compatibilist believes that the world we live in
is deterministic.
- What term (or phrase) corresponds to the following definition:
Suppose a person S does action
E. What theory would say that
even if E was determined,
provided S desired to do E1, had the power to do E, and there was no external
impediment stopping S from
doing E, then S’s action was a free action.
- What argument for compatibilism says (1) we are free because the
word “free” needs to correspond to actual cases of freedom and (2) even
if scientists discover the world is deterministic, compatibilism would
have to be true given that we are free.
- One criticism of classical compatibilism is that free will is not
merely the ability to do what one desires but involves the ability
to do otherwise. How might the compatibilist revise their
conception of freedom to accommodate this feature of free will?
- What theory of free will says that S is free to act otherwise provided
had they wanted (desired) to act otherwise, they would have acted
otherwise.
- Suppose Tek is determined to eat a cupcake. However, Tek says that
while he is determined to eat the cupcake, he has the ability to not eat
the cupcake. This, he says, is due to the fact that IF he had desired
not to eat the cupcake, he would have not eaten the cupcake. What theory
concerning free will does Tek likely hold?
- Suppose Liz desires X and
Y, but cannot have both. Liz
ultimately chooses X. Suppose
a metaphysician says the following “it is wrong to say that if Liz
desired Y she would have been
able to do Y since she did
desire Y (in fact, she desired
both X and Y) but she did not choose Y.” Given this objection, how should
the compatibilist revise their view on freedom?
- According to the compatibilist, which of the following best
represents the compatibilist’s view of a person that is free (even if
their action is determined). Let X and Y stand for different
actions.
- What term (or phrase) corresponds to the following definition: Free
will and determinism are incompatible and the free will is possible in
indeterministic worlds.
- Which version of libertarianism says that a subject S’s action is free if and only if
the action is nondeterministically caused by S (in any way).
- True or False. Non-causal libertarianism is problematic since it
says that every nondeterministically caused event performed by us are
free events, but some of these events are random and even against our
wills.
- Which version of libertarianism says that the following is a free
act: Tek lifts his hand, the lifting is nondeterministically caused, but
the lifting of his hand is not under Tek’s control. It is a random event
done by Tek.
- Which version of libertarianism says that a subject S’s action is free if and only if
the action is nondeterministically caused by mental events in S (reasons, desires,
intentions).
- True or False. One criticism of event-causal libertarianism is that
it appears that your reasons, rather than you, are responsible for the
choices you make. So, if there are two reasons R1 and R2, and there is a
.01 probability I will do R2 rather than R1, and, by random chance, I
think of R1, then I will do the action associated with that reason. But,
this strikes many people as not being a free act.
- True or False. Event-causal libertarians say that when an event is
free, what is required is that the actions that follow from your reasons
are nondeterministic. That is, they are not saying that the reasons
(mental events) a person has is nondeterministic but that the relation
between the reasons and the actions is nondeterministic in nature.
- Which version of libertarianism says that a subject S’s action is free if and only if
the action is nondeterministically caused by S via agent causation.
- What are the relata in agent causation?
- According to the agent-causal libertarian, when we make a free
choice, that free choice is due to events in our mind (or brain).
- Which of the following is one of the criticisms of agent
causation.
- True or false. One potential challenge to the belief that there is
no free will is the fact that people deliberate.
- True or false. Intuitively, if a person S deliberates about whether to do
action A or action B, then this implies that S believes that S can do A and can do B (although maybe not both A and B together).
- True or false. When a person S says they believe P but S performs an action that is
inconsistent with P, e.g.,
not-P, people contend that the
person really believes not-P. That is, people say “actions
speak louder than words”. However, this belief is not necessarily true
for two reasons. Indicate both reasons.
- Answer the following based on the course text / lecture. Suppose
either P or not-P is true (not both). And, suppose a
person has an inconsistent set of beliefs P and not-P. What are two reasons why there is
no practical benefit to removing one of the beliefs (P or not-P) to make your beliefs consistent?
Indicate both.
- What is the primary reason that philosophers contend that having an
inconsistent set of beliefs is so undesirable?
- One of the main problems with theories that deny the reality of free
will is that this denial comes with “unwanted” practical consequences
like (1) not being able to hold people morally responsible for their
actions and (2) criminal-justice reform.
- Which theory of punishment says that it is morally permissible to
punish criminals because they deserve to be punished (an eye for an
eye!)
- Suppose Mal commits a terrible crime. She is arrested and found
guilty. The court system says she is responsible for her crime and
deserves to be punished. “An eye for an eye” the people say! Which
theory of punishment best corresponds to the situation involving
Mel?
- Which theory of punishment says that it is morally permissible to
punish criminals because it prevents them (or others) from committing
similar acts.
- Suppose David commits a minor crime. He is arrested. The court
system says he is not responsible for his action but he will be severely
punished away. David’s punishment is published on social media so that
others are aware of the severe punishments associated with David’s minor
crime. What theory of punishment corresponds best with the scenario
above?
- Which theory of punishment says that it is morally permissible to
punish criminals because doing so helps fix them so they won’t do such
actions in the future.
- Suppose Ron is a basketball player. After a fan throws a beer at
him, he proceeds to attack the fan. The commissioner (boss) of the
league does not think Ron is responsible for fighting the fan but wants
to ensure that this type of event never happens again. Ron is thus
ordered to attend weekly therapy sessions for anger management. What
theory of punishment corresponds best with the scenario above?
- Which theory of punishment says that it is morally permissible to
punish criminals because doing so protects them and others from further
violence.
- Suppose Tek commits a crime. He is arrested. The court system says
he is not responsible for his action since his action was “determined”
(not free). However, Tek is still a threat to others (and others are a
threat to Tek since they are outraged by his crime). To prevent Tek from
hurting others, Tek is taken to a “secure facility” so he is separate
from others until the time where it is reasonably certain he won’t hurt
other people again (and others won’t hurt Tek). What theory of
punishment corresponds best with the scenario above?
- Essay Question: The three main theories of free will are
impossibilism, compatibilism, and incompatibilism. Your task is to
explain each theory. First, state what each theory says. Second,
illustrate each theory with an example. Your example should contain a
scenario involving a person committing some action.